Burg also said that his books original planned title was hitler won. Burg also said that his books original planned title. A book the journalist ari shavit, in the interview with the author published today in haaretz, defines as a farewell to zionism. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read my promised land. Interview with donald macintyre independent newspaper. In this award winning book that is both political and highly personal, veteran. That is how ari shavit, in his long interview with avraham burg published in haaretzs june 8 friday magazine, describes the characterization of israel in burg s new book, defeating hitler. Manhattan jcc hosting event with israeli antizionist. As ari shavit, a writer for the newspaper haaretz, said to him in an interview when the book was published here.
Forsaking israeli politics, avraham burg challenges zionism the. Avraham burg was speaker of israels knesset in 19992003 and is a former chairman of the jewish agency for israel. A failed israeli society is collapsing international herald tribune, 6. Burgs interlocutor for the haaretz article was ari shavit, a writer well. Jun 07, 2007 former knesset speaker and exhead of the jewish agency avraham burg has sparked quite a brouhaha with a. You may enter shavit s name in the upper corner search window for other discussions at this blog of shavit s views. His tirades against his country and nation were so primitive and offensive that haaretz journalist ari shavit roasted him, alleging that his book reeked. His father was yosef burg, a germanborn israeli politician and longtime government minister for the national religious party. His book ruminates about israel and zionism, compares israel and germany, harshly criticizes eichmanns hanging, reflects on judaism in the age of globalization and remembers his fathers house. Ari shavits my promised land is the best book written in recent years about the waning zionist empire. Ive been waiting most of my adult life for an israeli to plumb the deepest mysteries of his countrys existence and share his discoveries, and ari shavit does so brilliantly. Jan 15, 2014 israeli authorjournalist yossi klein halevi took the top prize in the 20 national jewish book awards, announced wednesday. As shavit reads it, burgs book rejects the very notion of a jewish state, claims that israel has no moral core and has become a brutal sparta fast sliding toward nazism.
Video and audio of burg discussing the holocaust among other things with gershom gorenberg on. It is sometimes difficult for me to distinguish between the primeval nationalsocialism and some national cultural doctrines of the hereandnow. Some of the most offensive remarks appearing in the israeli edition were also toned down. The occasion was the publication of burgs new hebrew book defeating hitler, of which few people in israel had heard until that morning. Avraham burg was a pillar of the israeli establishment but his new book is causing a sensation. Jeffrey goldberg, national correspondent, the atlantic ari shavits my promised land is without question one of the most important books about israel and zionism that i have ever read. If this is the secret of the book, it is also the source of its principal weakness. Sep 15, 2003 the end of zionism israel must shed its illusions and choose between racist oppression and democracy avraham burg. Needless to say, as haartez reports, burgs remarks have not sat well with many israelis. Shavits book was seen as a passionate but evenhanded explanation of his. Retrieved 20100718 retrieved 20100718 another way of understanding my book avraham burgs blog on themarker.
And his solutions are radical, as he explains to donald macintyre in shorts, tshirt and cotton kippa, avraham burg is sitting in his. Avraham burg, former knesset speaker and jewish agency chairman, who has come under criticism for a new book that includes a condemnation of israeli zionism, has called on current jewish agency. We must rise from its ashes with amy goodman and juan gonzalez on democracy now. Author of the awardwinning 20 book my promised land ari shavit hebrew.
The triumph and tragedy of israel by ari shavit november 19, 20 on. In this atmosphere of posttraumatic gloom, avraham burg, a former speaker. Defining israel as a jewish state is the key to its. What avraham burg is really saying the shalom center. Jul 11, 2007 a shallow place, thuggish, lacking spiritual inspiration. The ari shavit of this book often sees himself as the awareness, perhaps even the conscience, of israel as it could have been, as he would wish it to be. In an interview in haaretz weekend magazine, he said that he is in favor of. In an interview in haaretz in june 2007, burg suggested abolishing the law of return and stated that to define the state of israel as a jewish state is the key to its end. Burg not only walked away from politics, but also basically walked away from zionism. Israeli criticism of zionism and of israels treatment of the palestinians. Avraham burg former president of the jewish agency at 40 years of age and speaker of the israeli knesset at 45, after which he decided to quit politics at 50, in his book defeating hitler demolishes some of the ideological pillars upon which the zionazi state has been founded. Israeli authorjournalist yossi klein halevi took the top prize in the 20 national jewish book awards, announced wednesday. A book the israeli journalist ari shavit, in the interview with the author published in haaretz, defines as a. Forsaking israeli politics, avraham burg challenges.
In a new book, defeating hitler, and in a muchdiscussed interview in haaretz last week, burg argues that the time for herzls zionism is past. Burgs book is a contemporary example of this trend, and certainly provides grist for the propaganda mills of those whose objective is to undermine the jewish state. Let me recommend last years discussioninterview about the book between burg and ari shavit in haaretz part 1 and 2. The blind spots in the conscience and awareness of shavit in the book are also the weakness of the israel. Ari shavit, read the book and admits he detested it. Dec 20, 2008 four years ago avraham burg once talked about as a candidate for prime minister not only walked away from politics, but also basically walked away from zionism. Burg said he started his book in mourning for the loss of israel. By ari shavit, haaretz magazine we met 25 years ago. The interviewer, ari shavit, read the book and admits he detested it. A leftist israeli activist delivers a singular sermon explaining what needs urgent repair in the jewish democracy. A beautiful, mesmerizing, morally serious, and vexing book. Avraham burg di situs web knesset leaving the zionist ghetto by ari shavit haaretz interview, 24 june 2007. Avraham burg wikipedia bahasa indonesia, ensiklopedia bebas. Jan 25, 2014 there are two important stories about my promised land, israeli journalist ari shavits memoir cum interviews cum meditation on israel.
It will probably become a treasure trove for those seeking to utilize outlandish quotations demonizing the jewish state articulated by a former member of the israeli establishment. Remba, which explores different facets of israels predicament through a critical encounter with the work of ari shavit. He was the first speaker of the knesset to have been born in israeli territory after independence in 1948. Defining israel as a jewish state is the key to its end.
The jewish daily published june, 2007, issue of friday, june 15, 2007. Burgs interlocutor for the haaretz article was ari shavit, a writer well known in israel for his confrontational interviews and his cerebral opinion articles. Both movingly inspiring and at times heartbreakingly painful, my promised land tells the story of the jewish state as it has never been told before, capturing both the triumph and the torment of israels. This is the first in a series of essays by gidon d. Leaving the zionist ghetto by ari shavit haaretz interview, 24 june 2007. But the one that resonated best with my reactions is by avrum burg in. Avraham burg on ari shavits new book, haaretz, jan.
Avraham burgs book hitlers victory, published last year in hebrew, has now been released in english with a more neutral title the holocaust is over. There is a difference between saying nazi and saying nationalsocialist. As shavit reads it, burgs book rejects the very notion of a jewish state. Avrum burg, i read your new book, defeating hitler, as a parting from zionism. Avraham avrum burg is an israeli author, politician and businessman. Ari shavit draws on interviews, historical documents, private diaries, and letters, as well as his own familys story, illuminating the pivotal moments of the zionist century to tell a riveting narrative that is larger than the sum of its parts. As shavit reads it, burgs book rejects the very notion of a jewish state, claims. Ari shavit, author of my promised land journalist ari shavit says israel must find a way to reconcile its democratic values with the reality of everyday life there. Avraham burg is a leader of new israel fund, a leader of their international council as can be seen on the nif website. There are two important stories about my promised land, israeli journalist ari shavit s memoir cum interviews cum meditation on israel.
Navigating lost villages in israel the new york times. Burg was born and raised in jerusalems rehavia neighborhood. Oct 31, 2016 ari shavit, celebrated israeli columnist, resigns after sexual harassment accusations. His arabs are, for the most part, the faceless, nameless others of orientalist discourse.
In 2007, burg published a book called defeating hitler in which he claimed that israeli society is fascist and violent by the continuing trauma over the holocaust. In this book avrum burg addresses issues that affect us all beyond the confines of simple national, religious, and individual concern. Ari shavit, a writer for the leftwing israel newspaper haaretz, said of a recent book burg authorized that this book is antiisrael in the deepest sense. The end may be optimistic, but throughout its entire course the book repeatedly equates israel with germany. Paradoxically, the hebrew version of burg s book caused barely a ripple, for the simple reason that most israelis simply. Rabbi jonathan sacks and ari shavit were also among the winners. To avraham burg, former knesset speaker, former chairman of the world zionist organization and son of one of israels founding fathers, it is all of those things and more.
Shavit was a senior correspondent at the leftofcenter israeli newspaper haaretz before he resigned when a pattern of sexual misconduct came to public attention. In a courageous cover story, jewish journal senior writer danielle berrin detailed how a prominent israeli journalist, later named as ari shavit, groped and propositioned her during a professional. Avraham burg, one of the greatest promises of the israeli left, president of the jewish agency at 40 years of age and speaker of the knesset at 45, after which he decided to quit politics at 50, risks stirring a pandemonium. Yossi klein halevi wins national jewish book award the. Burg will not admit it, but from his point of view the book he is launching now, to coincide with hebrew book week, is a book of prophecy.
Jeffrey goldberg, national correspondent, the atlantic ari shavit s my promised land is without question one of the most important books about israel and zionism that i have ever read. Burg s interlocutor for the haaretz article was ari shavit, a writer well known in israel for his confrontational interviews and his cerebral opinion articles. And i discovered my father as a representative of german jewry that was ahead of its time. That is how columnist ari shavit, in a long interview with avraham burg published recently in haaretz, describes the characterization of israel in burgs new book, defeating hitler. The blind spots in the conscience and awareness of shavit in the book are also the weakness of the israel that once was and has changed unrecognizably. Ari shavit s new book, my promised land, has begun to bring into the mainstream discussion the idea that zionists must wrestle with the nakba. The spiritual sickness of avraham burg the jewish press.
Avraham avrum burg and i were then part of a small group of reserve soldiers and officers who came out against the first lebanon war. It is one of the achievements of ari shavits important and powerful book to recover the feeling of israels facticity and to revel in it, to restore the grandeur of the simple fact in. A book that is intended to vest the kingdom with prophecy. A short nyt portrait of avraham burg, an israeli politician who became a gerechter chassidey, righteous. Inside, in the papers weekend magazine, there was a long interview with burg conducted by the wellknown journalist ari shavit. The ari shavit of this book often sees himself as the awareness. Former jewish agency chief avraham burg rejects idea of a.
Joann mort, peace and pessimism in the promised land, dissent, dec. As shavit reads it, burg s book rejects the very notion of a jewish state, claims that israel has no moral core and has become a brutal sparta fast sliding toward nazism. But slowly i discovered the layer of not everything being lost. During most of the writing the book s title was hitler won. Former knesset speaker in favor of abrogating law of return, calls on israelis to obtain foreign passport. Ari shavit, celebrated israeli columnist, resigns after. Considering that burg is a scion of a distinguished orthodox zionist family, his radicalism scandalized almost everyone. The holocaust is over about a year ago, there was a huge culturalpolitical dustup in israel over the hebrewlanguage publication of his latest book in which he made a total break with israeli zionism. Anger and faith an open letter to my palestinian friends international herald tribune, 4. The triumph and tragedy of israel by ari shavit november 19, 20. A book the journalist ari shavit, in the interview with the author published today in haaretz, defines as a. The triumph and tragedy of israel ebook written by ari shavit.
In 2007, burg published a book called defeating hitler in which he claimed that israeli society is. That is how ari shavit, in his long interview with avraham burg published in haaretzs june 8 friday magazine, describes the characterization of israel in burgs new book, defeating hitler. Video and audio of burg discussing the holocaust among other things with gershom gorenberg on 12 february 2008 video or audio of interview with burg discussing his new. A shallow place, thuggish, lacking spiritual inspiration. It also captures burg s dark, cartoonish depiction of israel in the interview. Ari shavit s my promised land is without question one of the most important books about israel and zionism that i have ever read. You can vote id expect economist readers will largely vote yes, you can read the ongoing debate between avraham burg the left voting yes and daniel gordis the right. The haaretz writers very personal book on zionism is a tale that begins with high hopes and ends under an immense question mark. May 31, 2008 about a year ago, there was a huge culturalpolitical dustup in israel over the hebrewlanguage publication of his latest book in which he made a total break with israeli zionism. Avraham burg, former knesset speaker and former head of the jewish agency says to define the state of israel as a jewish state is the key to its end. Leaving the zionist ghetto by ari shavit we met 25 years ago. It also captures burgs dark, cartoonish depiction of israel in the interview. Shavit sees the book as an unempathetic attack on the israeli experience.
Forsaking israeli politics, avraham burg challenges zionism. Avraham burg s book hitlers victory, published last year in hebrew, has now been released in english with a more neutral title the holocaust is over. It argues that his country is an abused child which has become a violent parent. The triumph and tragedy of israel, published by scribe, is available from the guardian bookshop.
694 711 275 288 1252 1161 1438 296 170 1423 433 426 1245 628 320 1456 1421 449 501 1614 1612 1119 1441 652 1428 668 835 1080 1149 9 59 532 1380 1436 133 1043 32 1178 663 934